Our school previously used Admin+. In this program, the Excel Wizard feature made it easy to create a customized spreadsheet. Excel Wizard allowed us to scroll through available fields and select exactly the data we wanted to pull for any student or family. See screen shot of interface attached.
I hope you have been experimenting with our new lists for Students and Candidates. User List is coming too but still needs many more filters, and they will all expand with our monthly updates. I hope you will find the Lists format an easy way to create a customized report like you did before.